|
Predictably, the pre-game commentary from
the UK media about the Irish-All Blacks clash focused on all the negatives - the
Henry-Deans debate, the player brain/brawn drain, the half-empty stadiums, the
heretical talk from some attention-seeking people about not supporting the ABs
because of the World Cup fiasco. By contrast, the commentary on the actual game
played at the Caketin is reasonably even-handed:
In the NZ-baiting Times, Stuart Barnes drags
out most of the usual cliches about the end of All Black dominance and talks
about New Zealand being 'The New Samoa' - now playing the role for the Northern
Hemisphere clubs that the Pacific Islands supposedly (at least in the
imaginations of UK hacks) has played for the All Blacks - supplying an assembly
line of top shelf rugby talent for roving scouts. Barnes' over-arching point is
that globalism and professionalism are slowly killing NZ's grand rugby
traditions...
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/rugby_union/article4086187.ece
In his match report on the Irish-NZ test,
Barnes says NZ "wrenched" the the game away from the "Brave Irish":
"If this is the best that New Zealand can
muster then England - even a depleted England - should fancy their chances of
coming away from their two Tests over the next fortnight with a drawn series,
because this new-look All Black side is not a patch on the outfit that went into
the 2007 World Cup as red-hot favourites," Barnes opines.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/rugby_union/article4086095.ece
Providing a more even-handed assessment is
Chris Hewett in the UK Independent, who notes that if ever Ireland were to beat
New Zealand, this was the opportunity - given the battle-hardened all-Munster
pack, the new untried All Black squad selected just a few days prior, the
distractions of the Henry-Deans debate, the atrocious conditions at the Caketin and
the fact that that venue has proved the least successful home ground for NZ in
recent years.
http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-union/new-zealand-21-ireland-11-carter-brilliant-but-irish-miss-glorious-chance-to-end-hoodoo-842446.html
Flying the NZ flag in the UK press and
lambasting the continuing combination of bile and schadenfreude that British
hacks reserve for the All Blacks is our only World Cup winning captain and (my
former boss) Farfax Media CEO David Kirk, with this piece in the Daily
Telegraph:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.jhtml?xml=/sport/2008/06/08/srkirk108.xml
Also in the Telegraph, Paul Ackford, in a
reasonably argued piece apparently written before the Ireland test, argues that
England are the strongest they have been in years and have a real chance of
repeating their 2003 success against the All Blacks next weekend:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.jhtml?xml=/sport/2008/06/08/srackf108.xml
In the Guardian/Observor, Eddie Butler says
"the All Blacks flogged Ireland up front, picking and driving with a speed and
power that would have brought a murmur of approval from Munstermen, were not so
many of the Heineken Cup champions of Europe gritting their teeth and trying to
stop the flow". Butler also ponders whether on the basis of his performance at
the Caketin, Carter's new French employers are ruing offering him so much dosh...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2008/jun/08/newzealandrugbyunionteam.irelandrugbyunionteam
Finally, in the Irish Times, Gerry Thornley
says Ireland will "rue the one that got away":
http://www.ireland.com/sports/rugby/2008/0607/1212829542728.html?via=mr
|