|
Bledisloe test three, one all,
and all to play for. Not only Lord Bledisloe'sCup up for grabs, the winner
also wins the Tri Nations - as a secondary prize. The Australian's fresh
off their record loss (ever, to any nation) to the South Africans in Boerland,
and the All Blacks fresh off racking up 100 points in their opposed training run
against the Samoans. So who has the best preparation here!? The All
Blacks game though doesn't really count, as Samoa were very weak. The Boer
game though, does count, but the Aussies will be balls out to redeem themselves,
and it is going to be the All Blacks will be the ones on the receiving end.
HTML clipboard
It won't be an ambush though like the last loss
to the Wobblies, the All Blacks will be arriving at the ground with eyes wide
open. They have been improving each game too, and their last serious hit
out was the slow strangulation of the South Africans in South Africa. If
they carry that form and attitude into this game, then it will be another solid
win for the Men in Black...
The blouses
Aussie Caps 248 v All Black caps 214
Well to start, the Aussies have shifted 70 test
veteran Mortlock into 12, a move that might reduce his effectiveness, given that
he will be closer to the fatties, meaning less one on one changes to use his
strength for those freakish tries of his that he can score - and all to
frequently against the All Blacks! He's replaced by relative rookie Ryan
Cross at 13, who has just seven tests under his belt. This probably give
the All Blacks a slight edge here, with Nonu and Smith forming a nice
combination in the midfield, both now with plenty of experience in the big
games, with 20 and 27 tests respectively.
The back threes are probably break even, out
of sorts Sivivatu paired with centre come wing Kahui, backed up by currently the
best fullback in the world Muliaina. The Aussies have rookie Hynes with,
gulp, perhaps the currently best wing in the world Tuqiri, and Ashley-Cooper at
fullback. Could depend on Sivivatu - if he repeats his form from the All
Black loss to the Aussies though, it would be a points decision to the Men in
Black.
The All Blacks get a decision at the halves
too, Cowan and Carter a better combination that journeyman Cordingly and Giteau.
Although as we know, give Giteau an inch, and in typical convict fashion, he'll
take a mile. It's pretty much up to the All Black forwards though to
control Gits, by giving the Wobbly eight a good thumping - no front foot ball,
and half the battle is won.
The packs
Aussie Caps 332 v All Black caps 340
On paper, the All Black pack should,
should, I say again, on paper, should level this Aussie eight.
Al Baxter, not the flashest tighthead prop in the world, but with 59 tests under
his belt, knows how to cheat and drop the scrum and in general make up for a
lack of ability with a ton of cunning. Lets just hope that the Ref doesn't
get the wool pulled over his eyes with the antics of the worlds most capped
worst prop! joining him in a front row that should be beaten are a couple
of players that are of test quality, Moore and Robinson. Robinson I think
is developing nicely into a classy test prop - the Aussies have unearthed a
decent talent here, and Moore too is a never say die tough guy. They are
against a pretty decent trio though. Somerville at tighthead, who is still
fine in the set piece (lets not talk about his defence or ball skills, as there
is not a lot to talk about there), Hore, who has grown in leaps and bounds this
season, and Woodcock, generally regarded as the best loosehead prop in the
world. A tough trio, who should win the battle of the scrum for the Kiwis.
The locking duos are pretty equal in ability,
Thorn the engine room dynamo, and Williams the lineout king. The Aussies
have Sharpe in the Williams job - even more so if you ask our Aussie friends,
who think that he should be wearing a 13 on his back, as opposed to the four or
five he usually wears! The other lock that the Aussies have, the big
munter James Horwill is another goody unearthed by Australia. This guy is
going to be around for a very long time I think, and be a real pain in the arse
for many test sides as the years progress. Combine Horwill with Robinson
and Moore, and you have three-fifths of a decent tight five, but I digress.
The locking department, both packs well served.
The loosies, as per usual, it will depend on
the work of the tight five to give whichever trio the advantage. The
Wobblies are more used to working off the back foot, so even if the All Black
tight five get the edge, they will still be effective. However, if the
Wobblies get the upper hand (stranger things have happened), then Palu and Elsom
could run wild. However, the All Blacks trio of So'oilao, McCaw and Kaino
have formed a trio that is getting better and better by the game (now that they
are playing in their rightful positions), and will be hard to stop themselves,
regardless of the tight forwards efforts. Experience wise the Wobblies
might have a slight edge, but I think this comparison favours the All Blacks by
a shade.
The reserves
Aussie Caps 181 v All Black caps 122
Five forwards, two openside flankers on the
bench for the Wobblies. If that is not the biggest doffing of the cap to
McCaw in the history of the game, I don't know what is! Also opens
the Wobblies up for a world of pain should their backs suffer a few injuries
early. Their front row bench men scare no one though, Pudding Dunning, who
offers nothing but an extra drop goal option, and Adam Frier, who has not acted
since the Lord of the Rings trilogy - hobbits not being in demand at the moment.
On the other hand, the All Blacks, with prop John Afoa on the bench, increase
their on field presence when he makes the field, and despite his throwing yips,
Kevin Mealamu also ups the tempo when he arrives on the paddock. Weepu
also will add to the equation when he hits the paddock, as will Toeava, wherever
he might be put, from 12 though to 15. The other subs, Thomson, Donald and
Boric are more injury replacements, than impact players.
The verdict
All Blacks should take this match out, and
comfortably. But then, that was also the thought from the first Bledisloe
test, where the All Blacks were handed their arse on a platter! Anyway,
the tight five do their job, it should flow from there, and the win should come
after 80 minutes. Mortlock at 12 will be an interesting variation in the
Aussies game plan, will it work, wait for Saturday!
Australian team Stats:
15 Adam Ashley-Cooper (ACT
Brumbies) : 24 years : 19 tests : 1.82m : 98kg
14 Peter Hynes (Queensland Reds) : 26 years : 8 tests : 1.80m : 92kg
13 Ryan Cross (Western Force) : 28 years : 7 tests : 1.91m : 99kg
12 Stirling Mortlock (ACT Brumbies) : 31 years :
70 tests : 1.91m :
100kg
11 Lote Tuqiri (NSW Waratahs) : 28 years : 65 tests : 1.91m : 103kg
10 Matt Giteau (Western Force) : 25 years : 59 tests : 1.78m : 85kg
9 Sam Cordingley (Queensland Reds) : 32 years : 20 tests : 1.78m : 87kg
Backline tests: 248,
average 35.2
8 Wycliff Palu (NSW
Waratahs) : 25 years : 24 tests : 1.94m : 120kg
7 George Smith (ACT Brumbies, captain) : 28 years :
91 tests : 1.80m :
103kg
6 Rocky Elsom (NSW Waratahs) : 28 years : 39 tests : 1.97m : 106kg
5 Nathan Sharpe (Western Force) : 30 years : 68 tests : 2.00 : 115kg
4 James Horwill (Queensland Reds) : 23 years : 9 tests : 2.00m : 115kg
3 Al Baxter (NSW Waratahs) : 31 years : 59 tests : 1.90m : 116kg
2 Stephen Moore (Queensland Reds) : 25 years : 28 tests : 1.86m : 112kg
1 Benn Robinson (NSW Waratahs) : 24 years : 14 tests : 1.83m : 113kg
Forward pack tests: 332
tests, average 41.5.
16 Adam Frier (NSW
Waratahs) : 28 years : 23 tests : 1.75m : 98kg
17 Matt Dunning (NSW Waratahs) : 29 years : 41 tests : 1.82m : 115kg
18 Hugh McMeniman (NSW Waratahs) : 28 years : 16 tests : 2:00m : 114kg
19 Phil Waugh (NSW Waratahs) : 28 years : 74 tests : 1.75m : 100kg
20 Richard Brown (Western Force) : 32 years : new
cap : 1.89m : 106kg
21 Brett Sheehan (NSW Waratahs) : 28 years : 3 tests : 1.73m : 90kg
22 Drew Mitchell (Western Force) : 24 years : 24 tests : 1.82m : 95kg
Reserve tests: 181 tests,
average 22.6.
Total tests: 761, average 34.5
All Black
team stats:
1 Tony Woodcock (North
Harbour, Blues) : 27 years : 44 tests : 1.84m : 118kg
2 Andrew Hore (Taranaki, Hurricanes) : 29 years : 34 tests : 1.83m : 111kg
3 Greg Somerville (Canterbury, Crusaders) : 24 years : 64 tests : 1.83m : 126kg
4 Ali Williams (Tasman, Crusaders) : 27 years : 55 tests ; 2.02m : 112kg
5 Brad Thorn (Tasman, Crusaders) : 33 years : 19 tests : 1.95m : 113kg
7 Rodney So’oialo (Wellington, Hurricanes) : 28 years : 50 tests : 1.90m :
107kg
7 Richie McCaw (Canterbury, Crusaders, captain) : 27 years : 64 tests : 1.87m :
106kg
8 Jerome Kaino (Auckland, Blues) : 25 years : 10 tests : 1.96m : 109kg
Forward pack tests: 340 tests, average 42.5.
9 Jimmy Cowan (Southland, Highlanders) : 26 years : 16 tests : 1.82m : 91kg
10 Dan Carter (Canterbury, Crusaders) : 26 years : 53 tests : 1:78m : 91kg
12 Ma’a Nonu (Wellington, Hurricanes) : 26 years : 27 tests : 1.82m : 102kg
11 Sitiveni Sivivatu (Waikato, Chiefs) : 26 years : 29 tests : 1.85m : 100kg
13 Conrad Smith (Wellington, Hurricanes) : 26 years : 20 tests : 1.86m : 95kg
14 Richard Kahui (Waikato, Chiefs) : 23 years ; 5 tests : 1.86m : 95kg
15 Mils Muliaina (Waikato, Chiefs) : 27 years : 64 tests : 1.83m : 93kg
Backline tests: 214, average 30.5.
16 Keven Mealamu (Auckland, Blues) : 29 years : 59 tests : 1.81m : 106kg
17 John Afoa (Auckland, Blues) : 24 years : 8 tests : 1.83m : 126kg
18 Anthony Boric (North Harbour, Blues) : 24 years : 6 tests : 2.00m
: 110kg
19 Adam Thomson (Otago, Hurricanes) : 26 years : 7 tests : 1.96m : 112kg
20 Piri Weepu (Wellington, Hurricanes) : 24 years : 20 tests : 1.78m : 95kg
21 Stephen Donald (Waikato, Chiefs) : 24 years : 5 tests : 1.90m : 98kg
22 Isaia Toeava (Auckland, Blues) : 22 years : 17 tests : 1.81m : 92kg
Reserve tests: 122 tests, average 17.4.
Total tests: 676, average 30.7.
|